Is BRI-ARI consistent with the Rose
Report?
The Rose Report recommends the use of Synthetic Phonics (SP). SP is fundamentally Alphabetic Code-based reading and spelling
instruction. BRI-ARI instruction teaches a child how to handle
the whole Alphabetic Code in reading and
spelling. The instruction also incorporates matters of morphemic
characteristics (such as prefixes, suffixes, verb endings and
such) and syllabification.
The Rose Report notes the 'Simple Theory' of reading. That is,
reading is composed of two elements: 'Word Recognition' and
'Comprehension.' BRI-ARI instruction further simplifies the
teaching/learning by using text that is well within most children’s
spoken language repertoire. This essentially eliminates concern
for 'Comprehension.' The child does have to learn how to treat
written communication in the same manner one treats spoken instruction. Right from the start, children learn the 'how to' of comprehending,
just as they learn the 'how to' of blending.
With 'Comprehension' uncoupled, BRI-ARI focuses on the 'Word
Recognition'. This is a matter of first teaching the child to
handle the letter/sound correspondences that comprise the words
in a text. Together with rigorous attention to, and practice
of, decoding, BRI stories harness the expertise the child
has acquired in syntax through spoken language. Furthermore, the
books involve learning to handle punctuation marks, and such
conventions as contractions and abbreviations. From the very
beginning, BRI instruction encourages reading with automaticity
and fluency.
How can I prevent a child from continuing to sound out
and blend long after she/he is capable of reading text automatically?
The ability to blend sounds can take time to master. Most children
then naturally transfer to complete-word reading, but some require
specific direction. It may be as simple as prompting a child
that she/he can actually read the word in question without sounding-through-the-word.
A few children need to be prompted to progress to silently sounding
out any unrecognised word.
Why is it so wrong to encourage guessing for those children
who find decoding hard?
While it may appear to be the easy way out, the tactic of guessing
a word will eventually get the child into trouble. Guessing inevitably
leads to inaccuracy and the damage this does shows up very starkly
when the child is trying to tackle the Secondary School curriculum.
Skilled readers don’t guess words. They sometimes skip and skim,
but there is no short-cut to 'saying the sounds.' That
is what skilled readers do; they do it with automaticity and
they slow down on unfamiliar words. This is what you want your
child to learn how to do. Children try all kinds of short cuts.
Some of these are adaptive; others aren’t. Guessing words is
among the shortcuts that aren’t adaptive.
Why do you advise giving as little
help as possible?
Children are inherently very clever
at coping as easily as possible. They quickly and unconsciously
learn that waiting will bring help from the instructor. At worst,
this results in learned helplessness that is difficult to eradicate.
In BRI-ARI instruction some struggling with new code is healthy
and to be expected throughout the instruction. But all new correspondences
continue to be repeated with variations to give the child experience
in figuring it out independently. If your child has difficulty
with a correspondence (which may happen the first time it is encountered)
the best bet is to say 'The sound here is / /' and ensure the child
says the sound and reads the word. Nothing more is required, other
than giving praise for trying hard. You will find that he/she soon
encounters the same correspondence and will have an easier time
this time around and on each subsequent occasion. You will see the
learning happen before your eyes. In the view of the instructor,
some children need endless practice. But the child is going as
fast as possible. Don’t try to do it all in a single session. Space
the sessions to make the workload tolerable and as enjoyable as
possible. By frequently reading books earlier in the sequence,
your child will see the progress being made and experience reading
with automaticity and good expression.
My child has great difficulty remembering code. How can I assist without over-helping?
The best and easiest thing to do is to slow down. If the child is trying hard that is all that can be expected and all that is necessary. Encourage your child to read the books she/he has learned how to handle to anyone who will listen, and praise lavishly. If the child does not mind rereading the same books, do so as many times as necessary. Buddy/team reading with other books is also helpful. What you want to communicate to the child is: 'You are learning to read!' The structure of BRI-ARI ensures that the child will acquire expertise in handling text of increasing complexity with increasing independence. Whatever the pace and whatever the task, that is as good as learning/teaching gets.
What is reading fluency?
The term fluency is used very loosely in the field. It is identified with reading speed, because speed can be easily measured. That is maladaptive, particularly with tender beginning readers. Trying to go too fast, like trying to drive a bike or car too fast, interferes with other complicated aspects of the task.
In BRI-ARI the focus is on three aspects. Crucially, the text seeks to teach children to vary reading speed, in the same way conversational speech is controlled. It is appropriate to read some texts rapidly, other texts slowly. The child should be in charge. The second aspect is automaticity. The over-learning in BRI-ARI and the mantra 'Say the sounds...' insures that the response becomes automatic. That is, the child does not have to think about it. Again the analogy of driving a car is helpful. The third aspect is expression. This can be observed when the child is reading out loud. Once there is reasonable automaticity, the expression should match or even exaggerate the communication (like acting). This can be modelled and encouraged by the teacher/parent. What the child is saying out loud will be achieved when the child is reading silently. In this way she/he learns to gain the same enjoyment from written language as from spoken language.
Why doesn’t BRI include flashcards after BRI 1?
In any separate word practice, outside the context of text, it is impossible for a child not to memorize these words, irrespective of what he/she appears to be doing or is told to do. The essence of reading is doing these things in the context of text. That is exactly what BRI does. As the BRI protocol demands that your child’s approach to blending is right, it encourages the necessary skills and prevents use of any other technique.
My child has a good visual memory and seems to be memorizing words. Is the programme designed to encourage memorization?
This program is definitely not designed to be a whole word memorization programme; it is just the opposite. If your child is using the programme that way you need to click on GETTING STARTED and re-read the directions. The programme is designed to demand that the child 'say the sounds and read the word' without providing picture clues and by using words that look very much alike: Mit/Mat, sit/sat, fell/fill, will/well. Most if not all beginner readers will need to say the sounds as least one time to read these words. Some may look as if they are memorizing if they acquire automaticity very rapidly. Others need to do the blending many times to acquire automaticity. All children should slow down to 'say the sounds' sub-vocally when encountering unfamiliar words.
When should the notched card be discontinued?
As soon as your child learns what is involved in decoding, the notched card should be discontinued. You can then use the eraser end of a pencil to do the same thing when a new letter/sound correspondence is introduced.
How does BRI-ARI reading instruction help spelling?
If a child has learned how to handle the correspondences that form a word via reading instruction, spelling is largely reduced to the mechanical matter of writing the letters. Spelling is more complicated because one inherently has to generate the correspondences in the absence of letter cues. The BRI protocol is: 'Think the sounds and write the letters.' Children instructed with BRI-ARI can do this because they have previously learned how to 'Say the sounds and read the word.'